For years, every small business owner and blogger relied on newsletters to find new clients/followers and keep their fanbase loyal. And, for a long time, it was one of the best ways to reach people! However . . . we all know what happened. EVERYONE started getting hundreds of emails a day from various businesses, bloggers, and more. People got totally fatigued by all the content and all those newsletters went to junk.
So, should you stop writing and sending newsletters as a blogger??? No way! They are actually still a really useful way of reaching an audience and keeping your current audience engaged but only when done right. And, unlike the early days of the internet, a newsletter should not be your primary way of connecting with your target audience. That’s what search engine optimization is for!
A strategic newsletter can keep readers engaged, drive consistent blog traffic, win over interested readers, increase brand awareness, and build credibility among your audience. But, it has to be done right! The same old-same old isn’t effective in a modern world where people get a TON of emails. So, we’re going to dive into how to craft a newsletter that gets people to open that email, read your content, and travel to your website!
Here’s how to write a newsletter that actually pays off:
How To Write a Newsletter that Actually Drives Traffic
To put it simply, a newsletter is a way of keeping your audience engaged. Even if your followers love you, you’re constantly competing for their attention. The gap between blog posts, Insta reels, and other content can have readers forgetting about you FAST. A newsletter is meant to keep you fresh in their minds, reminding them of your great content.
That being said, a newsletter shouldn’t just be an advertisement for the content you’ve already posted or are going to post. It doesn’t inspire readers to urgently open and engage, because they can check out your website whenever they want and get all that same info in their own time without cluttering their inbox. Instead, your newsletter should provide a UNIQUE experience with original content.
Basically, think of your newsletter as a way to deliver exclusive, sought-after content that’ll have your followers anticipating everything you send out. We want them to know that the newsletter is the only way to get this content! Then, once they open the email and engage with that exclusive info, they can then interact with your CTAs that take them to your blog to read more, purchase something, join your membership, or whatever else you need!
See how a newsletter can really help when done right?
What Is A Newsletter?
A newsletter is an email that’s sent out to followers on a regular basis that’s meant to keep your readers connected and engaged. Your target audience gets this newsletter by volunteering their contact info on a sign up form (usually via a CTA on social media or your website).
There’s a lot that can be included in a newsletter, but it’s meant to keep your readers up-to-date on all things happening with your brand. It should include things like exclusive content, blog post previews, product announcements, specials/coupon codes, life updates, and more! They should be highly visual to be super engaging and include things like an eye-catching subject line. Just think about what your followers want to see and hear about regularly and craft your newsletter around that!
What Is The Purpose Of A Newsletter?
The purpose of a newsletter is simply to stay connected with your audience in a way that feels direct, personal, and consistent. Even if readers looooove your blog, life gets busy and the internet moves fast. A newsletter helps keep you on their radar by popping into their inbox with helpful updates, fresh ideas, and interesting content they actually want to read.
It’s also one of the few communication channels you fully control. Social media algorithms change constantly, but an email newsletter goes straight to your subscriber’s inbox. That means you’re not competing with endless scrolling to get your message across.
At the end of the day, a great newsletter keeps your audience engaged, builds trust over time, and reminds readers why they started following you in the first place.
What Are The Benefits Of A Newsletter?
Direct communication with your audience.
Creating a newsletter is a useful way to create a direct line between you and your email subscribers, allowing you to communicate without having to rely on unreliable social media algorithms. When you send a letter, it lands directly in their inbox, making sure they receive the updates, offers, personal stories, and other content. This is a great way to foster a personal connection with your audience. And, when they feel like their relationship with you is genuine, they’ll naturally engage more with your content!
Building trust and credibility.
Regularly sharing quality, honest content through your newsletter helps you establish yourself as an authority in your niche. When your audience sees consistent, high-quality information coming from you, it builds trust and credibility over time. This trust is SUPER important when converting casual readers to die-hard followers or customers!
Increased engagement and loyalty.
Successful newsletters can really enhance engagement with your whole audience. By inviting subscribers to participate in surveys, polls, or other CTAs, you encourage interaction that can really make them feel valued. Also, giving them exclusive content can boost loyalty, making them feel they’re getting something truly special.
Driving traffic to your content.
Quality newsletter content can really be a powerful tool for driving traffic to your website or blog. By including links to your latest blog posts, a landing page, products, or services, you can direct your audience to more of what you have to offer. For even better engagement, consider offering your followers an exclusive coupon code or access link!
Segmented targeting.
One of our favorite things about newsletters is the ability to segment your audience based on their behaviors, interests, and demographics. This means you can tailor your message to specific groups, ensuring that the content is relevant and engaging for each group of people. By doing this, you increase the chances of higher open rates and click-through rates and get more interaction on your website!
How To Write A Good Newsletter: What You Should Know
Step 1: Define your goals.
Before you start writing, it’s really important to know what you’re trying to achieve with your newsletter. Are you looking to inform, engage, sell, or something else? Defining your goals will help you shape your content and determine what metrics you need to track. Consider your audience’s needs and interests. Understanding what they want to see will guide your newsletter’s direction. This is your foundation.
Step 2: Know your audience.
Understanding your audience is crucial for creating great content that resonates. Take the time to analyze their demographics, interests, and pain points. This is a fantastic way to tailor your message to their specific needs.
Step 3: Create a compelling email subject line.
An email subject line is the very first thing your subscribers will see. A compelling subject line will encourage your audience to open and set the tone for the rest of the newsletter. Remember, a great subject line can REALLY impact your open rates.
Step 4: Create valuable content.
Now, you need to create the content. It needs to be unique, engaging, and not something they can find on your blog or social channels. The whole reason for signing up to newsletters is receiving content that is unique and exclusive. Always ask yourself: “How can my newsletter really add value to my audience?”
Step 5: Include clear calls to action (CTAs).
Every good newsletter should guide your readers on what to do next. Whether it’s visiting your blog, signing up for a webinar, or using a specific promotion, you need to use a clear and compelling call to action. You have to consider what you want your audience to take away from it.
Step 6: Make it easy to read.
A well-designed newsletter needs to be easy to read. Use a clean layout, clear visuals, and balance. Don’t forget to use your branded fonts and colors that are easy to read and mobile-friendly. Remember, first impressions do matter.
Step 7: Use email marketing software.
No standard email system can handle an extensive email list. You’d have to input EVERY email address and standard programs aren’t going to have any analytics to show you how well your newsletter is doing. So, make sure you use a user-friendly email marketing program that tracks all sorts of info about the newsletter, allows you to design emails within the software, and has the ability to send your newsletter out reliably to thousands of people! Some of the most common are Mailchimp, ConvertKit, and Substack!
Step 8: Send it out on a consistent basis.
To keep your readers engaged, they have to know what to expect. If you truly succeed at creating a KILLER newsletter, your followers are going to look forward to it! This is great, because it keeps you in the mind of your readers all the time. However, if you don’t send out your newsletter on a consistent basis, your readers will lose interest since they don’t know when or what to expect. Whether you send it out weekly, monthly, or quarterly, keep the newsletter consistent!
Step 9: Edit and proofread.
Before hitting send, take the time to edit and proofread your newsletter. Look out for any errors, typos, and inconsistencies. Try reading out loud to catch any awkward phrasing to create a smooth flow. If people read your email and find it’s low-quality, they likely won’t come back again.
Step 10: Analyze and improve.
With your newsletter sent off, it’s important to analyze its performance. Use metrics like open rates, engagement levels, and click-through rates to see what worked and what didn’t. Look for patterns and take note of them. You should always be improving to adapt to your audience’s preferences.
How To Optimize Email Newsletters With Content
Share content your subscribers can’t get anywhere else.
Think of your newsletter like a VIP section of your brand. Instead of repeating blog posts or social media content, offer something a little more exclusive that they can’t find anywhere else. Behind-the-scenes insights, quick tips, personal updates, or early announcements can make readers feel like they’re getting something special.
Focus on helping your readers first.
The best newsletters don’t feel like advertisements. They feel helpful. When your content solves a problem, teaches something useful, or sparks inspiration, readers will naturally want to click through and explore more of what you offer.
Make your newsletter easy to read/skim.
Most people will only check their emails quickly, and often on their phones. Keep paragraphs short, break up sections with headings, and use simple formatting so readers can scan your content without feeling overwhelmed.
Use clear and exciting calls to action.
Once readers are engaged, guide them to the next step. Maybe it’s reading a new blog post, checking out a product, or exploring a helpful resource. A clear call to action makes it easy for readers to keep interacting with your brand. Just make sure it’s engaging!
Don’t be afraid to let your personality shine.
Your newsletter is the perfect place to sound human and be YOU. Share a quick story, a personal observation, or something fun happening behind the scenes. That personality helps readers feel connected to you, not just your content.
How To Publish A Newsletter
Choose the right email platform for your needs.
Before sending your first newsletter, you’ll need a platform that manages your subscriber list and sends emails reliably. Tools like Mailchimp, ConvertKit (now Kit), or Substack make it easy to design emails, schedule them, and track performance.
Grow your email list naturally.
Your best subscribers are the ones who choose to join your list. Add signup forms to your blog, website, and social media pages so readers can easily subscribe when they enjoy your content.
Pick a schedule and stick with it.
Consistency is key when it comes to newsletters. Whether you send emails weekly, monthly, or somewhere in between, a regular schedule helps readers know when to expect new content from you.
Always send out a test email first.
Before hitting send on your full list, send yourself a test version. This gives you a chance to double-check formatting, links, images, and mobile layout so everything looks polished and professional. You need to be 100% happy with what you’re sending out!
Pay attention to your results.
Once your newsletter is out in the world, take a look at the data. Open rates, click-through rates, and engagement levels can tell you what your audience loves most. Over time, those insights help you refine your newsletters and make them even better.
What To Include In A Newsletter
- Compelling subject line
- Personal greeting
- Engaging content
- Visual elements
- Call to action
- Updates or announcements
- Exclusive offers and promotions
- Unique content
- Links to your latest content
- Feedback request
- Social media links
- Unsubscribe option
Nail your next newsletter with these tips!
Well, there you have it! Now you can craft a newsletter that helps you reach your goals and gain some engagement! Just remember that email marketing by itself isn’t a surefire way to get traffic. SEO needs to be your main focus and your email marketing should be a secondary tactic to back up your efforts. Just make sure your newsletter is an experience of its own and not repurposed blog content. This way, you can be sure to give your readers a unique experience!
If you need help with your SEO efforts to gain interest from your target audience, reach out to the team at InfluencerSEO today! While you wait for us to get back to you (you won’t be waiting long), make sure you have a read of our blog!
Jordan Becerra, founder and Lead SEO Strategist at InfluencerSEO, has spent almost 15 years in the creator internet space, the last nine building InfluencerSEO into the go-to SEO partner for content creators, with 500+ creators served from pre-launch to massive publication. She learned creator monetization and community building strategy from the inside working for Lauryn Bosstick of The Skinny Confidential prior to founding InfluencerSEO, so she understands both halves of the game: how search actually works AND how creators actually build a strong community online and make money. Her job now is to stay ahead of where search engine optimization is going, especially as AI rewrites the rules, and to make sure the creators she works with get there first.
Leave a Reply